Tax Burden Of Sin Taxes On Tobacco Products Economics Essay

In mundane activities, whether in leisure or career, consumers seem to be reminded about the necessity of paying revenue enhancements. Besides leisure and work ; some consumers even have had sin revenue enhancements firing their pockets due to their misbehaviors. Sin merchandises have had revenue enhancements as one of the grounds for monetary value lifts and merchandises, such as baccy merchandises, have had revenue enhancement levied on them to the extent of exerting the “ trueness ” of the consumer ‘s true demand of ingestion, but all of the effects of revenue enhancements seem to be impacting the consumers and non the manufacturers, is that truly the instance? The constructs of revenue enhancement incidence can be used to reply this inquiry and other inquiries, such as who decides how the load is shared and whether this makes any important difference, by depicting the revenue enhancement load and how it is shared between consumers and manufacturers. Applications such as analyzing the snap of demand and supply, which is fundamentally looking at the reactivity of consumers due to monetary value alteration, is critical in the survey of revenue enhancement incidence and will be used through out as the wickedness revenue enhancement load on baccy merchandises is discussed.

Sin revenue enhancements are meant to command ingestion of baccy merchandises, amongst other merchandises, at the same clip they raise excess gross for the authorities ( cite article ) by raising merchandise monetary values through a punishment revenue enhancement doing consumers to reconsider buying the merchandise, for assorted grounds, yet harmonizing to the October article companies are paying for their wickednesss in the signifier of high revenue enhancements ( Pile, 2008 ) . Which raises the inquiry ; on who does the load truly lie or is it shared every bit? The reply lies in the theory behind revenue enhancement incidence and market behaviour due to monetary value alteration. Due to the fact that the consumers are paying for the merchandise, a simple reply might be that manufactures effort to go through on the load to the consumers ( Mohr & A ; Fourie, 2005 ) . That might be true but to a certain extent but it depends on the monetary value snap of the demand and supply of coffin nails ( Mohr & A ; Fourie, 2005 ) .

Due to revenue enhancement incidence we say that the load of revenue enhancement levied can be studied through analyzing market behaviour, the instance in which the whole revenue enhancement being paid by the consumers will be considered foremost. To show the importance of demand and supply snap, different instances of snap will be used. The undermentioned figure employs the thought of all of the wickedness revenue enhancement being included on the purchase monetary value of a sin merchandise viz. cigarettes.

In the revenue enhancement incidence where all the revenue enhancement is paid by the consumer, the demand of the coffin nail packs lessenings due to monetary value lift of 1.00 euro ( from 3.00 to 4.00 euros ) , therefore switching the demand curve to the left. The monetary value received by the provider decreases, due to the fact that demand has decreased and fewer units will be sold, by 1.50 euros ( from 3.00 to 2.50 )

Diagram obtained from ( Parkin et al, 2005 )

The figure below illustrates the revenue enhancement incidence when all of the money is accounted for by the provider.

In the revenue enhancement incidence where the provider histories for all of the wickedness revenue enhancement, the willingness to provide of the provider lessenings due excess costs incurred of 1.50 euros therefore the monetary value paid by the consumers will stop up increasing besides to cover those costs and the money received by the provider is still 0.50 less ( from 3.00 to 2.50 )

Diagram obtained from ( Parkin et al, 2005 )

In the instance above one can observe how the provider seems to free 0.50 euros and consumers pays 4.00 euros regardless of whether the provider or consumer pays the whole revenue enhancement. In this instance a revenue enhancement incidence can be noted that the revenue enhancement is non shared every bit as the consumer pays 1.00 euro of the revenue enhancement ( from 3.00 euro equilibrium monetary value to 4.00 euro ) and the provider pays 0.50 of the revenue enhancement ( from 3.00 euro equilibrium monetary value to 2.50 euro ) and regardless of where the load lies, the result is the same. How it is the result is fixed and how it consequences in this kind of revenue enhancement incidence? This is all due to how elastic or inelastic the demand and supply is.

The demand snap of a merchandise can be used to see how the revenue enhancement will be shared when the revenue enhancement is charged on consumers or paid by providers, therefore it is necessary to research the construct of monetary value snap. Price snap of demand is ( non done here )

In the instance where consumers pay the revenue enhancement, it would ensue in the increase of the merchandise ‘s monetary value and the demand snap will make up one’s mind by how much the measure demanded will fall, for case, the more elastic the demand is so the more the measure will fall due to monetary value alteration and the more the provider would hold to “ pay up ” , how so? Due to the fact that the provider will provide the measure demanded, if it where to fall so the provider would provide less than the possible sum therefore free a certain sum in the procedure. In the instance where the provider pays the revenue enhancement, so the provider is willing to provide less due to the excess cost incurred, the sum the provider is willing to provide will wholly depend on the snap of supply, for case, if the supply is inelastic so the alteration in monetary value would non ensue in a immense autumn in measure supplied intending the provider would non free that much but in a instance where the supply is really elastic, it would ensue in a big autumn of measure the provider is willing to provide and a big sum would be lost.

In order to make up one’s mind whether the sin revenue enhancement of baccy monetary values is shared every bit between the consumer and manufacturer or non, from what we know, it is necessary to happen out the snap of baccy merchandises. The monetary value snap of demand in China was -0.15 in 2008 and -0.50 in 2009 ( Jian, 2009 ) but what does this truly intend? The monetary value snap of any merchandise is the ratio of the per centum of measure alteration to per centum of monetary value alteration of that merchandise and merely the absolute value is considered intending the demand snap in China for baccy merchandises was 0.15 in 2008 and 0.50 in 2009. The monetary value snap being less than 1 means the measure alteration is less than the monetary value alteration therefore the demand for baccy merchandises was inelastic.

The diagram below is an illustration of how the revenue enhancement incidence in China would be ; it is non precise and is merely used to give assistance to apprehension.

In the revenue enhancement incidence where the demand snap is absolutely elastic, it is noted that the consumers bears the full load. Like the tobacco users today and baccy users, no affair how much the monetary value alterations they still seem to be addicted. Due to their inelasticity providers can bear down them excess with the wickedness revenue enhancement and they will still demand the same measure, therefore they bare the whole revenue enhancement. What does that intend about the effectivity of bear downing wickedness revenue enhancement since it ‘s meant to command baccy merchandises use?

Diagram obtained from ( Parkin et al, 2005 )

Some tobacco users or baccy users are considered to be somewhat inelastic ; these include pupils, low income consumers and hapless tobacco users or users. From the findings noted above about perfect inelasticity, sin revenue enhancement poses no difference on those users and the consumers bare the full revenue enhancement. On consumers that are comparatively inelastic, most of the load lies on the consumer but, depending on the snap of supply, providers might bare some of the revenue enhancement load since those hapless tobacco users, low income users and non employed pupils might make up one’s mind to discontinue.

From analyzing the revenue enhancement incidence and demand snap, much can be noted about the consumer behavior, but what of the provider behavior? That ‘s where supply snap plays a function. Suppliers supply a certain measure harmonizing to the costs incurred and organize that supply snap can be studied ( Jian, 2009 ) . Supply snap merely depends on how far the provider is willing to travel. Resources used and picks dictate the provider ‘s snap, therefore a economic job arises every clip for the providers as there are ever limited resources and from that, it is merely logic that the supply can merely de monetary value rubber band. Since supply is elastic, consumer will therefore bear most of the snap ( Mohr, 2005 ) ; note that irrespective of how you look at it, consumers of baccy merchandises will ever bare the wickedness revenue enhancement load.

Is the sin revenue enhancement load of baccy merchandises every bit shared between consumers and providers? From the surveies carried out above, decidedly non, unless providers can happen a manner to economically turn and cut down the job of scarceness, leting them to portion the load every bit, otherwise the consumers will ever bare most of the wickedness revenue enhancement if non all of it and on the inquiry of the effectivity of the wickedness revenue enhancement, baccy use is merely controlled to a certain extent as habit-forming users prove to be loyal to their dependence

1485 Sum WORDS




Student NUMBER: 382853

Coach Name: _______________