A Comparison Of Two Method Of Desalination Environmental Sciences Essay

Despite the deficiency of H2O in some countries of the universe in one manus, and the increasing ingestion of it in some others make it indispensable for scientists and applied scientists to seek for practical solutions for this universe crisis. This paper closely examined the sea H2O desalinization to be one of the most widespread methods that provide the universe with a considerable sum of potable H2O in footings of quality, measure and cost. Desalination of Seawater is an attack used ( and may be the lone method ) to get the better of deficit of fresh H2O from natural resources in many parts in the universe. In recent old ages, many desalinization processes become technically and economically low-cost. The production of one three-dimensional metre of desalinated H2O becomes really moderately to be less than $ 1/m3 for many new installings.

2. Introduction

Desalination Industry is driven by desalinization procedure such as Multi Stage Flash ( MSF ) and Reveres Osmosis ( RO ) . Operationss of these procedures and commanding them are really complicated due to many grounds. Many research workers tried to analyze dynamic behaviour of desalinization workss to turn to works variables during operation.The works closure can take to considerable affects or effects on the works economic sciences ( see Fig. 1 ) .

Fig. 1 Influence of Plant Factor[ 1 ]on Plant Economics.

In many researches and new installings, efforts to develop much better and dependable control policy have been investigated and many more are still on traveling under research. The effectual public presentation and rating of different control strategies is of import and possibility of implementing new control policies can open new Windowss for operation of desalinization workss for close hereafter.

At the same clip, this research besides aims to better our apprehension of controllability and operability of the desalinization workss for better, safer and economic works operations with maximising productiveness, handiness and profitableness. The survey accomplishment is believed to be good for desalinization community and it helps developing local MENA human resources significantly.

3. Purposes and Aims:

Study dynamic behaviours with controllability of MSFs and R.O procedures. Emphasis on alone features of desalinization procedures such as physical, chemical and fluid kineticss will be considered,

Simulation of the two methods will be developed on — – to measure the response of a classical desalinization system to different operation scenarios based on conventional control strategies.

Addressing desalinization system constituents in control policy such as airing public presentation in capturing non-condensable gases, fouling rate formation in capacitor tubings, and seawater flow fluid mechanicss fluctuations,

Computational Fluid Dynamics will be used to depict some complex desalinization works dynamic behaviour and phenomena such as seawater entrainments to distillate trays and mist eliminator efficiency, and brine degree alteration with opening constellation,

Economic analysis justification for implement iterative Learning control in thermic desalinization workss.

4. Why the Work is Important:

Recent development of procedure and control methodological analysis of the desalinization works behaviour utilizing its operating informations. The integrating of public presentation and procedure control will let better controllability the workss even during failures ‘ events.

Addressing some dynamic phenomena in the workss and public presentation of some workss ‘ constituents will be covered with use of Simulation. Economic analysis of implement different the control system will be done. Furthermore, this undertaking will assist in developing cognition capacity and human resources in MENA part.


This survey will turn to two of the most widely used procedures of saltwater desalinization. El-Dessouky and Ettouney argue that, the thermic procedures or membrane separation methods are best methods for desalinization procedures ( 2002: 11 ) . Based on this point, we are traveling to analyse an illustration of each type, viz. MSF and RO.

Multistage Flash:

MSF is considered to be one of the thermal-based procedures to desalt saltwater. Simply put, saltwater goes through a procedure of vaporization followed by that of condensation. Based on this observation, we may reason that the procedure at manus imitates the sort of vaporization that occurs in nature. The mechanism in which this takes topographic point is explained by the National Research Council ( 2004: 76 ) who points out that:

MSF uses a series of Chamberss, each with in turn lower temperature and force per unit area, to quickly zap ( or “ brassy ” ) H2O from majority liquid.The vapor is than condensed by tubings of the inflowing provender H2O, thereby retrieving energy from the heat of condensation.

As it turns out, heat is the chief beginning of energy needed for this procedure to take topographic point.

FIGURE- 2. Multistage flash. Beginning: Buros et Al. ( 1980 ) ; Buros ( 2000 ) .

Rearward Osmosis:

RO is viewed as one of the membrane-based procedures to desalt saltwater. In this method high force per unit area during semi-permeable membranes permeates the fresh H2O of extremely concentrated seawater solution ( El-Dessouky and Ettouney 2002, P. 12 ) . Therefore, the efficiency of this technique is chiefly dependent on how good the membranes are in dividing salts, metals and other stuffs from H2O. Unlike other membrane procedures, RO relies on the force per unit area put on saltwater against the membrane, the higher the force per unit area the better. The undermentioned flow chart explains this procedure: ( RBF Consulting, 2004 )

Figure- 3 Seawater Reverse Osmosis Plant SOURCE: RBF Consulting 2004.

Three standards will be considered to look into the advantages and disadvantages that each method has: The Quantity and Quality of the Produced Water: Harmonizing to RBF Consulting ( 2004 ) , the fresh H2O produced by MSF constitutes around 61.6 % of the desalted H2O in the universe. This is, of class, non unusual since this method has been used since the mid 1940s. Specifically, the desalted H2O produced in winter is more than that in summer. Obviously, this does non follow with what is required. To work out this job, we might guarantee that the works is provided with high temperatures all the twelvemonth about. However, this might take to the gradual corrosion of the works equipment.

On the other manus, the sum produced by RO comprises about 26.7 % of the overall production as indicated by RBF Consulting ( 2004 ) . Interestingly, Saudi Arabia is ranked 2nd in the universe with about 12.9 % of the desalted H2O produced by RO. However, the sum produced by MSF is about twice every bit much as the sum produced by RO. The following tabular array shows the alteration in the capacity of the desalted H2O in Saudi Arabia:

Table 1 ( El-Dessouky and Ettouney 2002, P.15 ) .


Entire capacity

( m3/d )

Percentage relation to entire universe production

MSF ( % )

RO ( % )











Water Desalination in the UK. This is considered to be new in one of the wettest states in the universe. This inclination towards this beginning of potable H2O can be ascribed to two factors: First, there has been an increasing anticipation or fright of desiccant summers. Second, the changeless growing of population makes it necessary to rapidly happen options to H2O beginnings. This is really a point of difference between Saudi Arabia and the UK. Specifically, Saudi Arabia ‘s production of desalted H2O will needfully be much bigger than that of the UK, because Saudi Arabia is thought to be one of the driest topographic points in the universe.

As for the method adopted in the UK, it has been argued that RO is preferred to MSF as being less expensive. This follows from the decrease in the capital costs of membranes, which finally leads to the decrease in the operational costs. Indeed, RO is chosen to desalt H2O in the Beckton Plant in East London which is meant to take saline H2O from River Thames. This works is expected to make a capacity of 150 MLD that will be sufficient for 400.000 families as indicated by Bennett ( 2005 ) .

Equally far as quality is concerned, it is apparent that H2O produced by MSF is really pure. However, the pureness of the H2O produced by RO depends on the efficiency of the membrane. In other words, it relies on the ability of the membrane to gaining control minerals, salt atoms and stuffs. Therefore, we may state that pureness is one of the advantages that MSF has over RO.

The Cost of the Produced Water:

The disposition of some states to follow RO in saltwater desalinization although it provides less pure H2O can be linked with the lower costs required for this procedure. Dickie ( 2007: 11 ) argues that big graduated table thermic desalinization has been wholly limited to the rich, energy affluent and H2O hapless states nearby the Arabian Gulf.

Based on this observation, we may account for the broad usage of MSF in Saudi Arabia since this state is rich with energy beginnings required for this procedure as discussed before. This besides justifies the usage of RO in the UK as being less expensive. In fact, RO tends to be the optimum method to desalt saltwater all over the universe.

4. The Team Work:

This undertaking is based on a MSc plan in the University of Newcastle and it will set up a promising cooperation between two R & A ; D organisations ; Saline Water Conversion Corporation ( SWCC ) and School of Chemical Engineering and Advanced Materials in the University of Newcastle.

The rule research worker, Nasser Zouli, is a member of taskforce squad of undertaking on public presentation of desalinization workss in the ( SWCC ) . The undertaking has evaluated more than 20 desalinization workss.